Tithi Mondal

Guide6 min readUpdated

How to Evaluate a Logo: A Checklist Before You Approve

How to evaluate a logo with a practical checklist: test it at small size, in black and white, on real surfaces, and choose between logo concepts.

By Tithi Mondal, UI/UX Designer

Read inहिन्दीবাংলাमराठीதமிழ்తెలుగుગુજરાતી

How to Evaluate a Logo: A Checklist Before You Approve: cover illustration

The designer sends you three logo concepts at 11 pm. On the big laptop preview they all look good. You pick one in the morning, print 500 visiting cards, and find that the name is unreadable on the card and the logo is a grey patch on your Instagram circle. How to evaluate a logo is a skill you can learn in 30 minutes. To evaluate a logo means to test it in the real places and sizes where customers will see it, before you approve it and before any printing starts.

Here is the checklist I would use as a client, and the one I expect clients to use on my own work.

How do I test a logo at small size?

Shrink the logo to about 30 pixels tall on your screen and see whether you can still tell it apart. If the shape and name are readable at that size, the logo will survive on a phone.

Most people in India meet your brand on a mid-range Android phone. The logo will appear as a tiny square in a chat list, a round profile picture or a browser tab. Test these:

  • WhatsApp profile circle. Save the logo and set it as a test profile picture. Corners get cut off in a circle.
  • Instagram avatar. Same test.
  • Browser tab icon. About 16 pixels. Only a simple shape survives.
  • Phone in sunlight. Hold the phone at arm's length and walk to a window.

Things that fail often: thin lines, small taglines, many small shapes, and long names. If the tagline disappears, that is normal, and it is fine to drop it for small uses. But the name or the main shape must stay visible.

Ask your designer for a small-space version, such as the symbol alone, if the full logo fails. A symbol alone or a short lettermark often suits small spaces.

Does the logo work in black and white?

A strong logo still works when it has only one colour. Print the logo in black on white paper, or convert it to greyscale on screen, and check that nothing important is lost.

You need a black and white version more often than you think. Stamps, newspaper ads, courier stickers, embroidery, receipts and photocopied forms all use one colour. A logo that depends on a colour gradient or two similar shades falls apart there.

Check these points:

  1. Are shapes still separate, or do two similar colours merge into one grey?
  2. Is the text still readable?
  3. Does the logo look balanced when the colour is removed?
  4. Does a reversed version, white on black, also look good?

If you receive only a colour logo, ask for a one-colour version and a white version. These are part of a standard package. Ask for vector files, transparent PNG files and light and dark versions.

Is the logo simple and easy to remember?

A good logo can be described in one sentence and drawn from memory in rough form. Try the memory test: look at the logo for 10 seconds, turn away and describe it to someone.

If you cannot describe it, it is probably too complex. Cut it down. Simple shapes are easier to see on a signboard, on packaging and in a scroll feed.

Also check the idea behind it. Ask:

  • What does the shape say about the business?
  • Would a stranger guess the field, or at least not guess the wrong one?
  • Does it avoid common, overused images, such as a generic globe for every company?

Overly clever logos are a trap. A hidden arrow or a secret letter is nice to have, but it is not the goal. The goal is quick recognition. Whether a designer or an AI tool made the logo, the same test applies. I compare the two in AI generated logo vs designer logo.

Does the logo look right on real surfaces?

A logo only proves itself when you see it in place. Place it on a mock-up or even a quick screenshot of your real material: the shop board, a bill, an Instagram post, a carton label, a letterhead.

Ask your designer to show it in 3 or 4 of your real uses, or make a rough check yourself in Canva or PowerPoint. Test on:

SurfaceWhat to look for
Dark backgroundDoes a light version exist, and is it readable
Photo backgroundDoes the logo stay clear on a busy image
Visiting card, 90 by 50 mmIs the name still legible
Signboard, seen from 10 metresIs the main shape visible
Invoice or billDoes it print well in one colour

Print the logo on plain paper at your actual card size. Look at it for a minute. This one paper test finds many problems that a screen hides. For uses on boards and cards, read shop signboard and storefront branding and business card and letterhead design.

How do I choose between logo concepts?

Choose between concepts by scoring them against the same short list, and not by which one you like at first sight. Scoring makes the difference clear and keeps feedback useful.

Use a simple score from 1 to 5 for each concept:

  1. Readability at small size.
  2. Works in one colour.
  3. Fits your business and customer.
  4. Different from competitors nearby.
  5. Works on your top 3 real surfaces.
  6. Will still feel right in 5 years.

Add up the scores. Then ask 3 to 5 people who are your real customers, not only family and friends. Show the concepts without telling them which one you prefer. Ask, "Which one would you trust with your money?" and "What do you think we sell?"

My own logo package includes 3 concepts, so there is a real choice. I also ask clients to pick based on use, not taste alone. If two are close, choose the one that wins at small size.

Remember that you can mix. It is common to take the shape of concept B and the font of concept A. A good designer will welcome that conversation. Read how to give design feedback for ways to say what you feel clearly.

Before you approve, check the spelling, the files and the rights, because these cannot be fixed easily after launch. Treat approval as a checklist and not as a feeling.

  • Spelling and spacing of the name. Read every letter aloud. In Bengali or Hindi, check each joined letter.
  • Colour codes. You should have the exact codes for screen and for print.
  • Files. Vector, PNG with transparent background, light and dark versions.
  • Guidelines. A short document that says how to use the logo.
  • Clear ownership. Agree in writing that you own the final logo. See design contract and NDA basics.
  • Similarity check. Search for similar logos in your field.

Take one night before you say yes. Then look at the logo again in the morning on your phone. If it still looks right, approve it.

If you want a logo with 3 concepts, 2 revision rounds and a ready file set, in 3 to 5 days, you can see my logo design service.

Frequently asked questions

How small should I test a logo?

Test it at about 30 pixels tall for screens, and also at your real printed card size. If the name or main shape is still clear, the logo is strong.

Why does my logo need a black and white version?

Stamps, newspaper ads, stickers and photocopies use one colour. A one-colour version keeps the logo clear in those places.

How many logo concepts should I look at?

Three is a good number. It gives a real choice without causing confusion.

Should I ask friends and family which logo is best?

Ask them, but give more weight to real customers. Show the concepts without saying which one you prefer.

Working on something like this?

Tell Tithi what you are planning. You get a clear scope, a fixed price and a timeline before any work begins. I reply to every enquiry within 24 hours.

Your details go only to Tithi and are used only to reply to you. No newsletters, no sharing.

Have a product in mind? Let us design it properly.

Tell me what you are building. I will reply with questions, a rough timeline and a quote.